All she has to do is say no. It is as simple as that.
Eve opens her mouth to say the words. “No! I told you, the Lord God said that we would surely die if we ate from that tree.”
Eve opens her mouth, and the words form on her lips. But then her eyes meet those of the serpent. She hears its voice echoing in her mind. “Did God really say, ‘You shall not eat from any tree of the garden’?”
She wants to respond bravely, as she did just a moment ago. “Oh no, from the fruit of the trees in the garden we may eat. It is only this tree in the middle of the garden from which God has said, ‘You shall not eat of it, lest you die.’”
How proud and how confident you were then! You, Eve, who knew that you had nothing to fear. Why should you eat from the forbidden tree? You are not hungry. You need nothing.
Eve was inclined to scoff and turn away at the ridiculous suggestion.
But something stopped her.
Maybe it was the serpent.
Eve had seen any number of beautiful snakes, with shining green, gold, and red scales. She loved to watch them skillfully wind their long, slender bodies through the trees, climbing as well as the monkeys with their many legs, their scaly bellies never touching the ground. Snakes, she maintained, were some of the most beautiful creatures the Lord God had created – even though Adam thought they were, perhaps, a bit too clever for their own good.
Perhaps they were. But all the same, something seemed different about this one.
The fact that it possessed the powers of language wasn’t strange. Eve frequently held conversations with the animals, admiring the snakes’ scales or the birds’ songs. But she had never before heard any creature suggest that God might lie.
The concept, not of God lying, but of anyone lying, was entirely new to her. The concept of evil was new. The feeling of fear and distrust that she felt, watching the serpent, was new. What was evil? What was good? What was death?
How should she know? Eve had been alive for three beautiful, heavenly weeks, and she had never had a burn, a cut, or a scratched finger. She had never eaten flesh. She had never felt pain. She had never seen death.
And yet, Eve, you want more. Is it not enough to live in Paradise? Is it so hard not to eat from one tree?
Ah me! I must not be too hard on Eve. She does not understand what is at risk. She does not know what sorrow is - indeed, she does not know that sorrow exists. Having never known it, she cannot fear it. Oh, Eve! hesitating there before the tree of doom! If only some angel would intervene, and snatch the fruit from your reach!
Eve stands there, reflecting on the past. She blinks, and moves her eyes from the riveting glow of the serpent’s. Once more she opens her mouth to say no.
But the serpent interferes. “I tell you, you will not die! God knows that the day you eat from it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.”
Truth, the serpent speaks – truth. You will know evil, Eve – evil beyond anything your feeble imagination can show you. You will know pain, sorrow, sickness, murder – and death. God knows all this sorrow – he has spared you from it. Would you willingly tear down his protection? What good gifts do you imagine he is hiding under the guise of that fruit – what is it that Eden lacks which you suppose that golden globe somehow contains? Is there some joy missing from Paradise? If there was, could you not ask the Lord God for it rather than stealing it, since he never fails to walk with you in the breezy time of the day? Can you improve the Lord God’s perfect world by embracing what he has rejected and discarding what he has gifted? A lie wrapped in truth, evil disguised as good – that is what hangs from this tree!
Eve, say no – no, Eve, flee from this place. Speech means nothing – your powers are not strong enough – run, run, and never let yourself near again. You are on the edge of a cliff, and you are falling – flee, flee now while you can, and save yourself!
Eve turns away from the serpent. But her eyes linger and at last come to rest on a golden fruit.
How beautiful it looks!
Eve hesitates. The fate of a universe is being decided. If only she understood what she is doing!
Slowly her hand reaches out. Slowly, winding through the tree like the serpent beside her – her beautiful, beautiful hand reaches out. I see it – I see it bearing a sword, and striking millions dead – I see it stealing, and killing, and hating, all while its owner looks on with that same guilty gaze. It is wrong, she knows – but she does not know how wrong it is! Stop while you can, Eve! never mind whether it is very evil or not – that is for God alone to know. That it is wrong must be enough!
As her hand reaches through the trees, I see the sorrow, death, and agony of a universe. I see innocents condemned to death as the serpent’s eyes glow brighter amid the shadows. A cloud draws before the sun, casting a shade on the shining tree, and making the fruit lose some of its luster – one last gift of Heaven’s mercy to the tempted!
But it is too late. Eve’s fingers open – beautiful, womanly fingers – and they close on the fruit. I hear a deathly thud, as a hammer drives a nail – through a human hand into the fruit tree.
But Eve is unaware. She pulls, twisting her hand slightly – a simple motion. There is a snap as the stem breaks. I see a body broken with it. And I see a woman in blue, and she cries out and clutches the body to her heart.
Eve brings the fruit to her lips, opens her mouth, and tastes it. I cringe at the sound of her teeth. “It makes sense...” she murmurs.
Adam looks anxiously over her shoulder. Adam? I had forgotten he was there. Adam, why did you not try to stop her? One may easily succumb to the pressures of temptation – but there are two of you! One should have supported the other!
Poor Adam – why do I scold you? Why do I expect you to do that which Eve could not? You too are under the enchantment of the fruit - you, too, believe the lies of the serpent – and why would you not? You also do not know what will come of your sin, and you, like your descendants after you, cannot see the necessity of obedience even without understanding. Ah, me – expecting you to be strong where I would be weak! In your place, would I be any stronger? Could I, who have never seen God, succeed where you, who walk with him daily, have failed?
Eve looks at the fruit. Adam watches her carefully. “Is it... good?” he asks at last.
A bit of golden juice runs out of her mouth. She nods. “Will you have some?”
He takes the fruit, and bites it just as she swallows. There beside her, in the shadows, he cannot see the change that has come over her face at the moment of ingestion. She starts, and opens her eyes a little wider.
He, too, starts as he bites the fruit. As he takes it away from his mouth, he sees that the golden flesh has suddenly turned black.
Yes, the fruit tastes splendid to him – better than any fruit he has ever had. But when he sees the black, rotting flesh within, he is loath to take another bite, and rapidly swallows what he has already taken.
With that swallow, somehow, everything seems different. Adam and Eve have swallowed something besides fruit – they have swallowed the spirit of the foul serpent, and unless God himself should intervene, that spirit will be inherited in all their children forever, born in each and every one as original sin.
Eve turns, and their eyes meet, opening wider as they look at each other.
Without a word, Eve turns and runs. Adam looks after her, blinking. Then he looks down at his own unclothed body and does the same.
***
It is never any help to run from God.
He knows what my ancestors have done, though in shame and terror they refuse to admit their guilt, pointing fingers at each other, at the serpent, anywhere except themselves. They do not even say that they are sorry. (What good would that do, Eve wonders bitterly. It would not make their sin go away, it would not erase their guilt. Nothing, Eve thinks in despair, nothing can do that now.)
The serpent has infected their souls, and there is no cure. The Lord has not taken Paradise from Adam and Eve - they have taken it from themselves. For by no measure of mercy can it be restored to them, until the dark serpent has been evicted from their souls.
The Lord punishes the serpent, removing the beautiful legs Eve has so admired. He casts Adam and Eve into the world of mortals, a world in which they will work and die. No longer will the animals live and speak as their friends, for the natural world, too, must suffer for their disobedience.
Adam and Eve, clothed in their thin, ragged robes of leaves, stumble out of the garden – a place never to be seen by living man again.
But Eve is a woman of courage.
“Will you turn your face from us forever?” she cries.
The earth trembles, waiting for his response.
“No,” says the Lord. The world is dark, dreary, and cold – only the unknown lies before them – but somehow, Eve feels a comfort in the simple monosyllable she herself was not strong enough to utter.
The Lord God gives Adam and Eve each a cloak of animal skins, warmer and stronger than those of leaves, having been made with divine hands. Yet Eve shivers more, recognizing in the skins that which once belonged to life, and seeing how it is now serviceable only in death.
So it will be with her and her seed.
“By the sweat of your face you will eat bread, and in pain you will bring forth children. And I will put enmity between you and the serpent. But you shall strike at his head, while he strikes at your heel.”
***
Four thousand years have passed.
All she has to do is say yes. It is as simple as that.
Mary opens her mouth to say the words. “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord. Let it be done to me according to His will.”
Mary opens her mouth, and the words form on her lips. But she is bewildered still. For a moment she closes her eyes, and listens to voices echoing in her mind. “You have found favor with God,” the angel said. “You will conceive and bear a son, and you shall call him Emmanuel.”
Mary was frightened. “But – Joseph and I are only betrothed right now,” she heard herself wonder. “And even after – that is, without breaking my vow of virginity – well, how can this be?”
“The Holy Spirit will come upon you,” responded the angel. “Therefore, the child to be born will be called the Son of God.”
Does that mean what it sounds like it means? It raises many more questions than it answers. All of reality seems turned upside down, shaken and shattered and rewritten. Never, ever, has Mary imagined any woman, much less herself, the mother of a child called God.
There are more immediate practical considerations to worry about, too. What will her parents think? What will Joseph think – how can she explain this to him? What will the rabbi say? She will be cast out of the synagogue in shame, believed guilty of disregarding the Lord’s holy law regarding marriage – she, who would rather die than break even the smallest commandment. No, it will be worse than that – pregnant outside of marriage, she knows she should be stoned, without miraculous intervention she’ll never live long enough to give birth. Joseph will doubt her and divorce her – her friends will abandon her – she will be all alone.
Nothing makes sense. Mary looks for courage.
And then a voice whispers in her ear.
I see its owner, though she does not. It is a woman, clutching a robe of animal skins over a dress of fig leaves.
“Say yes,” whispers the woman, and in her eyes is the pleading of a universe. “Say yes, and I will go with you – God will go with you.”
Slowly Mary’s hand reaches out. Slowly, winding through her blue robe – like Eve’s hand, so many years before – her beautiful, beautiful hand reaches out. I see it – I see it cradling a child, and lifting up the fallen – I see it giving to the poor, and bandaging the wounded, and healing the sick, and embracing the friendless, and loving – I see it cradling a broken body that was nailed to the Tree of Knowledge! – all while its owner looks on with that same wondering, trusting gaze. It is right, she knows – but she does not yet know how right it is! Say yes, Mary: never mind that you do not understand – this is for God alone to know. That it is right must be enough!
As her hand reaches, I see the sorrow, death, and redemption of a universe. I see innocents rising from their graves, I see a furious army turned back at her touch – and, what is this? I see the serpent’s eyes glowing brighter than ever against the shadows of his brow. He is whispering in Mary’s ear – he is telling her to say no – his eyes are blazing with the fires of evil and hatred. He strikes at the heel of the woman dressed in the leaves, and she cries out in pain. A cloud pulls away from the sun, letting a ray of warm light fall on Mary – one more gift of Heaven’s mercy!
And Mary looks up. Slowly she smiles. Her fingers open – beautiful, womanly fingers – and they close over each other in prayer. I see Adam biting the fruit – he stops, and his eyes grow wide, and he kneels before the tree, on which hangs Mary’s Child! I see Eve, drawing her foot from the serpent, and crushing its head in victory!
But Mary is unaware. She kneels before the angel, twisting her hands slightly – a simple motion. There is a creak as she gently drops to the floor, and her knees crush the serpent forever. She opens her mouth, and the words flow freely, and a child is conceived.
And I see Eve, weeping in the garden before the Tree of Knowledge, holding the forbidden fruit. It is heavy, like a stone sealing a tomb. She looks up, drops it, and clasps her hands. There is a noise, and there is a light.
And the apple rolls away.