The Judgement of Pontius Pilate
What a boring day of judgement, dear.
I didn’t even get to everyone.
Another Hebrew says a soldier stole from him
(He probably did, but we won’t prosecute),
The thieves, the prostitutes (whom we’ll just whip
And send back to their work). I have this fear—
Not just that the courts are never quite fair.
(Though I do hate the flattery, the games,
The “contributions” made in prisoners’ names)
But I also mean—I didn’t eat today
And they’re all on trial for such similar things.
It’s hard to feel I’m thinking clear enough
To be an honest judge of anything.
I feel that sort of fear about that man.
Oh, you remember—you had that dream about him,
Then everybody said he wasn’t dead.
It’s funny, usually I get annoyed
with things like that: these stupid superstitions,
These Hebrews, I ought to be in Rome. All that.
But I was wishing it were true, with him.
What a man! I’ve never seen a man
With so much—ah! No word is full enough.
I asked him if he was the Jewish King
(Revolutionaries always answer “yes”)
But his answers were the strangest thing:
You’re the one calling me a king, and then
Something about him coming down like light
To manifest the truth of God, then
That he was a king, but in another world.
And the Jews had said he was the Son of God.
I know the gods are only in the heavens.
I do. I know the poets are just poets,
That when they talk about the gods descending
They only mean to help us understand
By analogy, the mysteries
Of the beginnings, growings, hurtings, endings
Of all things. I know that when all’s done,
After the fleshy stench of sacrifice, that
The fields of stars where the gods run, and the spheres
Of secret music where all life comes from
Turn and return with cosmic indifference.
But I had the thought (I know it’s blasphemous)
Of a trickster god in a tunic of flesh, pretending
To be a Jewish man I had to judge.
No—not a trickster. A sad god.
And noble. If gods could be men they’d resemble him.
And something about that made me want to tremble.
I wasn’t really worried about the gods.
I was afraid of something else: maybe
All we’d heard of the universe was wrong.
Maybe some Other truth was truth, and That
Would beggar or redeem our bleary world.
I’ve never felt a fear like that. I asked him
“What is truth?” But he didn’t say a word.
Prisoners are silent all the time.
You know how I get with that, my dear.
That’s when I’m at my best—I get indignant:
“Be a man! Would you let your shyness kill you?
Don’t you know I can sentence you to death
At will if you don’t make a good defense?”
But he said what I’ve often thought myself:
This power of mine, condemning or restoring,
Is only mine because it’s given me—
But he said given from above, And then
As though he knew I was afraid, He said
My guilt was relatively light.
What a man. Condemned, yet for half an hour,
He was the judge and I was dumb before him.
But what could I do? Frankly, I loved the man.
Don’t laugh! I did. In that strange way you can
Only ever love an awesome stranger.
It happens with the enemy in war—
The ones who laughed, who loved a noble death—
But it was war, just like this was judgement.
I had the peace to keep, and you to think of,
And little Claudius. Caesar brooks no rival
And Jesus was a man to rival him
If ever was. I’m proud of what I wrote
Above him, though. I wanted to call him king
So, in my way, I did. I like to joke
(Like the thief we crucified beside him did),
That I hope he remembers me when he gets his kingdom.