A deep darkness enveloped the forest once the sun had dipped below the horizon. The headlights clicked on, illuminating a pothole-ridden road. An array of stars pierced into the skyline like a million eyes watching, and the moon smiled menacingly just above the trees.
Inside the old blue Volkswagen, the only sound was from the rumble of the tires and the growl of the engine. Liam stared out the windshield, his eyes bloodshot and his stubble greying. Get help! He could still hear that same thought, ringing in his ears, in his head, in his soul. All these years later. Can someone hear me?!
Mile markers flew by in a blur of green and white, with the occasional splash of yellow, blue, or brown. Boom, crash, thud. There were no words that could adequately describe the sound of the crash, but it was stuck in his mind, like a feeling you just couldn’t shake.
Soft, flickering lights popped up a ways down the road as he crested a hill. Liam started to slow down, gently pressing the brake, until he came to a full stop before mile marker 33. He stared at the illuminated sign for a moment and glanced around. There were no other lights than from his car, and the electric candles that lined several yards around the sign. He stepped out of the Volkswagen—leaving the engine running—crossed the beams of light, and approached the sign, as he fidgeted with the rosary in his pocket.
Boom, crash, thud.
He pulled the rosary out and held it up. It sparkled pink under the high beams. He could still hear the gasp Maddy Lou had let out. There was hardly time for any more of a response before the vehicle hit the ditch.
He hung the rosary on the side of the mile marker and watched reverently as it thumped a couple times against the metal. It had been years—years since Liam was here last, since the accident, since that night. He reluctantly looked down into the ditch. Someone, probably Maddy Lou’s father, had planted some rose bushes down there, a splash of red here and there from the blooms.
Liam had checked the vehicle out before leaving home, but it had still failed. A tire flew off, and when he slammed on the brakes, the car shuddered but continued its trajectory, swerving into mile marker 33. It flew off the road and landed hard in the ditch. The airbags only deployed on the driver’s side.
Liam put a hand over his eyes, like he was trying to tear the mental image from his brain—Maddy Lou’s face, dripping with red. He had reached out a hand to her, but she was already gone. The pink rosary slipped from her fingers and dropped out of sight.
Liam shut his eyes tighter. How could he have let this happen? He detailed the truck, kept everything up to date, and did everything he needed to. Or did he? Doubt crept in as an unwanted guest, but one he couldn’t refuse.
Boom, crash, thud.
Maybe this was why his friends had advised that he not come here right after the accident. The emotions were palpable, thick in the air of this now-sacred place. It had taken him so long to get to the point where he could even get out of bed or leave home. And when he did, he almost hoped for another accident—a miraculous one—to take him this time. But that inevitably brought him right back to the thought of the first accident, how it happened, what led up to it. He had checked the truck, kicked the tires, and made sure everything was in order. Nothing was out of place. He had driven it for years before and had no accidents. So how could this have happened?
Boom, crash, thud.
The sound reverberated in his head, much more heavily now. He ran his hands through his hair as he fell to his knees. The rosary slipped through her bloodied fingers. Her blank eyes stared back at him, a sweet smile still gracing her lips. Then Liam was in the hospital. A man in uniform brought him the rosary, which was still stained with blood.
Liam let out a cry to bring himself back to the present day, out of the agonizing memories. You killed her. The thought came to the surface, making it explicit. You killed her and need to pay for it.
Liam’s fingers pressed firmly against his skull in an attempt to pull the thoughts from his mind, with no success. No, I didn’t know. I checked. I swear, I checked!
His mind went silent. Owls hooted, crickets chirped. But the world became quieter.
Maddy Lou stood there, in the aisle at the back of church, smiling up at Liam, who was in awe of the beauty before him. As she processed down the aisle, everything else melted away. Her father, the church, the priest. It was just the two of them. Just the two of them and the prayers they used to pray together.
Lord, grant us the gift of faith, even as much as a mustard seed, so that we may move mountains. Amen.
That stung the most. After the accident, he had not been to Church except for the funeral. That was Maddy Lou’s deal. He would have left sooner, had she not been so devout and virtuous. But now he couldn’t go. There was no way. She was one of God’s most faithful servants, and, if He is real, He gave her such an unpleasant, unnatural death.
God loves you. Maddy Lou’s voice rang in his mind. She said that many times. And he almost began to believe it. Since she was gone, there were two holes in his soul now.
Boom, crash, thud. Smile.
Liam’s blood ran cold. What was that? He thought back to the crash. The tire flew off with a boom, then crashed through mile marker 33, then thudded right into the ditch. What happened next? He had looked over at Maddy Lou’s face, marked with red. The rosary slipped from her fingers, thumping against the floor, out of sight. He had looked out the shattered windshield at the dark woods. There, almost imperceptible, was a face, looking straight into Liam’s eyes, into his soul. It held a smile on its papery white face, its eyes as big as tennis balls, its pupils infinitesimally small.
Goosebumps came over Liam. He stood up from his position on the side of the road, a sense of unease and urgency coming over him. Leave now, his mind told him. He turned to head toward his Volkswagen, but stopped in his tracks.
“Don’t leave me,” said a sweet, kind, female voice.
Liam trembled, his heart pounding in his chest. Walk to the door and get in, he told himself. Drive away. That was just your imagination. And whatever you do, don’t look at the woods. But it was so distinctly present a voice that it was undeniable. Someone was watching, he knew it. And he hoped he knew who it was, given that he recognized the voice. He slowly turned his head to look out at the woods.
Something blinked.
Liam’s gaze narrowed in on the eyes that peered out at him. They were illuminated, almost as though a source of light came from within them, but the rest of the face was still cast in shadow. Liam tried to call out, asking who was there. But his mouth was too dry, and he could not even get one word out before coughing. He cleared his throat and tried again. “Who’s there?” his voice shook. He hoped the onlooker didn’t notice. “Hello?”
“Don’t leave me,” said the voice again. This time, Liam could hear it more clearly. It was definitely Maddy Lou’s voice, which felt so refreshing and surprising that he did not even notice the low, dull ringing accenting the voice, like that of a broken whistle.
“Maddy,” Liam said, his voice cracking.
A pale, white face came out of the darkness. Its grin spread wide between each side of its face. Wiry strands of hair, like metal cables, protruded from all sides of its head. Sharp, jagged teeth clacked in its mouth as it spoke. “That’s what her last thought was, that night.” Its voice had reshaped. Now it was a deep growl, the dull ringing still accenting each syllable. “Madeline Louise.”
Liam froze. He could almost not comprehend what he was looking at. He wanted to run to the car door, but his feet were stuck to the pavement.
The face sneered. “Isn’t it ironic? She was the one who left you.”
“W-What are you?” Liam sputtered.
“You know what I am,” the face said. It kept getting closer, showing no sign of a body. The darkness just extended out into the light, keeping the rest of the being hidden to the naked eye. “But you can call me Death, for I hold Maddy Lou in my hands.”
“Let her go,” Liam said, a little more forcefully than he thought he was capable of in this moment.
“If you wish,” the face said. Its grin kept widening. Then it opened its mouth until it was five feet tall.
“Liam!” Maddy Lou’s voice pierced Liam’s ears. It was frantic and frightened. She looked out of the mouth. “Liam! Help me!”
Liam jumped forward toward Maddy Lou, but the mouth closed just before his fingers grazed her hair, leaving him only inches away from the face.
“She is gone,” the face rumbled. “Her body is decaying in the dirt. But you need not accept it. You have everything you need to bring her back. Eye for an eye, life for a life, soul for a soul.”
Liam’s fists clenched. Boom, crash, thud. How could he refuse? It was his fault she died, so it was his responsibility to bring her back. He felt his heart beating against his chest, as if trying to pull him toward the face. He had to look away. “How do I know you’re good for it?” His voice came out in another whimper. “Are you really that powerful?”
“Dear boy,” the face’s voice growled, the dull ringing ever louder. “You know what I am and you know that I am infinitely capable. You would be a fool to refuse.”
Liam stepped to the side, closer to the mile marker, the rosary still swaying there in the gentle breeze. “Maddy Lou,” he whispered, his voice cracking. Give me a sign, he begged in his mind. What should I do? He put a hand on the rosary.
“What do you say?” the face growled. “Shall you remain a fool?”
Boom, crash, thud. Smile. That smile was in the woods, partially hidden by shadow. Its eyes pierced through the darkness, illuminating its jagged teeth.
Boom, crash, thud. The sound started to take more the shape of a heartbeat, his own rapidly quickening. Boom, boom, thump. One heartbeat and the rosary hitting the floor. The rosary.
“You were there that night,” Liam said.
The face didn’t need to wait for Liam to finish saying what he was thinking, or even to complete the thought in his mind. “I do nothing,” it said. “I am not a creator. I built neither man nor object. But I can bring one back.”
Liam closed his eyes tight. What would Maddy Lou do? Is she safe? Is she in heaven? Is she--?
“Closing your eyes is merely a temporary escape from reality,” the face said. “Sooner or later, you will ask me, and I will be ready.”
“Is Maddy Lou in heaven?” Liam asked the question before he could stop himself.
“No,” the face said without hesitation. “Heaven is a construct built by man to ease his grief.”
Liam looked over at the rosary, gently swaying in the breeze. He could feel himself gaining back control, as though the face’s words boosted his certainty. “So it’s true.”
“Every word I’ve said,” the face said, grinning.
Demons lie, the voice in Liam’s head reverberated. Trust them at your own peril. He reached out a hand to grab the rosary, but the space between him and the mile marker warped, lengthening unnaturally.
“And a fool you shall remain,” the face snapped. “I offered you your love! Would you not sacrifice everything for her? Why would you reach for the last thing she held, when you could watch her hold it again? Tell me! You killed her, you must atone!”
Liam started walking toward the mile marker, feeling the face’s breath on his cheek. He kept his gaze fixed on that pink rosary, which stayed fixed in place, neither swaying in the wind nor growing closer.
“Pitiful!” the face screamed. Warm, red, liquid flew from its mouth, drenching Liam’s shirt and the ground around him. “Maddy Lou deserved better than you. It is good she died, so she wouldn’t have to live with you. Your entire existence is an insult to her memory!”
Liam felt like someone punched him in the gut. His heart sank and his stomach turned over. That’s right, he thought.
No, a louder voice in his mind said. Move the mountain. Move the mountain, William.
Liam broke out into a sprint, keeping his gaze fixed on the rosary. His blood boiled. With every fast, firm footfall, his rage burned hotter. Those thoughts don’t mean a thing. Move the mountain. He could hear the face shrieking and crying, but its voice was becoming incoherent.
Liam focused on the rosary again, its beads still glinting under the high beams. Come on! he thought as his legs began to ache. A pain pierced his abdomen. He breathed as deeply as he could as he sprinted all the harder. The rosary was closer now. He stretched out an arm, but it was still not close enough.
Move the mountain!
Boom, crash, thud.
Boom, boom, thump.
Hail Mary. . .
The prayer broke through the noise. Liam ran into the sign and fell onto his back on the concrete. The rosary landed on his chest. He grabbed it, clutching it in his hands as he scrunched his eyes closed and curled up into the fetal position. He felt a harsh, rushing wind around him, along with an unholy, shrill, agonizing scream. Then silence. Then the chirp of crickets and hoots of owls. Liam sat and looked up. The high beams still illuminated the area, but the face was gone. The electric candles flickered.
Liam panted, attempting to catch his breath. He held the rosary up, the beads glistening. He kissed the crucifix and put it over his head like a necklace, the little Jesus swaying by his heart. Standing up, he wiped the sweat from his face, then walked back to the Volkswagen and drove off.